When the 1999 Constitution was being drafted, the legislative draftsman never had the intention of giving the Judiciary immunity.
But something happened in 2017 that made the Judiciary give itself one.
In June 2017, the EFCC indicted and arraigned Hon. Justice Hyeladzira Ajiya Nganjiwa at the Lagos State high court on a 14-count charge.
Before the arraignment, Hon. Justice Hyeladzira Ajiya Nganjiwa was a serving judge of the Federal High Court of Nigeria.
What was his offence?
According to the EFCC, between 2013 and 2015, the judge allegedly received unexplained and questionable financial inflows into his bank accounts totalling approximately $260,000 and ₦8.65 million.
Before his trial could proceed, Justice Nganjiwa, through his counsel, Robert Clarke, SAN, filed a Preliminary Objection challenging the jurisdiction of the Lagos State High Court.
Why?
He argued that, as a serving judicial officer, by virtue of Paragraph 21(b) and (d) of the Third Schedule to the 1999 Constitution, he could not be subjected to criminal prosecution in a regular court unless the allegation had first been submitted to, investigated by, and decided upon by the National Judicial Council (NJC).
He tried to convince the court that permitting executive law enforcement agencies to directly arrest, detain, or prosecute serving judges for actions connected to their judicial capacities would paralyse the Judiciary and violate the doctrine of Separation of Powers.
The EFCC, on the other hand, argued that Section 308 of the 1999 Constitution strictly limits criminal immunity to the President, Vice President, Governors, and Deputy Governors, and that judges are explicitly excluded from this protection.
When Hon. Justice Adeola Akintoye of the High Court of Lagos State listened to the objection, she was not convinced by the argument of Hon. Justice Nganjiwa, so she dismissed it.
She held that criminal liability applies universally and that serving judges do not enjoy constitutional immunity from prosecution.
Hon. Nganjiwa was not satisfied with the judgment of the Lagos State High Court, so he appealed to the Court of Appeal.
On December 11, 2017, the Court of Appeal, led by Justice Mohammed Lawal Garba, delivered a unanimous judgment setting aside the trial court’s ruling and striking out the charges against Justice Nganjiwa.
The EFCC was not satisfied with the ruling, so it went straight to the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court, in a judgment written by Justice Centus Nweze and read by Justice Adamu Jauro, dismissed the appeal.
According to the apex court, initiating criminal proceedings against a serving judge without first reporting the matter to the NJC directly violates Section 158(1) and Paragraph 21, Part I of the Third Schedule to the 1999 Constitution.
The court strongly noted that allowing executive law enforcement agencies, such as the EFCC, to directly arrest and prosecute sitting judges at will is a “grievous assault and an affront on the Separation of Powers.”
Hence, it could not sit idly by and watch the creation of such a constitutional hazard, as it would leave judges vulnerable to intimidation by the Executive arm of government.
That was how Hon. Justice Nganjiwa was discharged.
The case of Nganjiwa became a precedent that shields serving judges from direct prosecution without first following the prescribed NJC process.
Hon. Justice Hyeladzira Ajiya Nganjiwa is still a judge, currently presiding at the Warri Division of the Federal High Court of Nigeria in Delta State.
The case is cited as Federal Republic of Nigeria v. Hon. Justice Hyeladzira Ajiya Nganjiwa (2022) JELR 111506 (SC).
I am Ekene Aninze, Esq.
Copied



